Borax vs OxiClean: What You Need to Know

Note: Some links are affiliate links, and I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support!

It’s laundry day, and your favorite shirt has a stubborn stain that just won’t budge. Should you choose the trusted Borax, favored by grandmas, or the modern powerhouse OxiClean? 

As a household product expert, I’ve extensively used both. Borax excels at general cleaning and deodorizing, while OxiClean is a champion at tackling tough stains and brightening whites. Both have their strengths, so let’s dive into the specifics to help you decide which one suits your cleaning needs.

Ingredients and Composition: Borax vs OxiClean

Borax and OxiClean are two popular cleaning agents with unique ingredients. Each is effective for different cleaning needs. Let’s see what makes them special.

Natural Borax

Borax, or sodium borate, is a natural mineral from dry lake beds. When mixed with water, it breaks down into boric acid and sodium ions, making it effective for cleaning, killing mold, and even controlling pests. It’s also eco-friendly!

Powerful OxiClean

OxiClean’s main ingredient is sodium percarbonate. It’s a mix of washing soda and hydrogen peroxide. This mix is great for cleaning.

When you add OxiClean to water, it releases hydrogen peroxide, which breaks down stains. It’s like a burst of bubbles attacking dirt.

Comparison Table: Borax vs OxiClean

FeatureBoraxOxiClean
Main IngredientSodium TetraborateSodium Percarbonate
Natural or SyntheticNaturalSynthetic
Cleaning ActionMild, multipurposePowerful stain remover
Environmental ImpactEco-friendlyHigher environmental footprint
Common UsesLaundry, cleaning, pest controlLaundry, stain removal, deodorizing
SafetyNon-toxic, mild skin irritationCan cause irritation, use gloves
Best ForEveryday cleaning, eco-conscious usersTough stains, deep cleaning tasks

Uses and Effectiveness: Borax vs OxiClean

Borax and OxiClean are both powerful cleaners, but they excel in different areas. Let’s see how each one performs for your cleaning needs.

Household Uses of Borax

Borax is a versatile household helper that can make cleaning and pest control easy. Here’s how you can use it around your home.

Cleaning and Laundry

  • Laundry Booster: Borax makes your laundry detergent work better. It helps remove stains and softens hard water. I tried different brands, but I liked Home & Country USA All-Natural Borax the best. My clothes felt clean and fresh.
  • Stain Remover: It’s great at tackling tough stains like grease, oil, and protein-based spots on your clothes. When I used Harris Borax Powder Laundry Booster, the stubborn oil stain on my favorite shirt disappeared!
  • Dishwasher Detergent Booster: Adding borax to your dishwasher detergent helps prevent hard water spots on your dishes and glassware. Pure Original Ingredients Borax has been a game-changer for my glassware, leaving them sparkling clean every time.
Borax For Cleaning and Laundry
Borax: Your Cleaning Ally

Household Cleaning

  • All-Purpose Cleaner: Mix borax with water to clean countertops, sinks, and bathroom surfaces. It’s like a magic potion for grime! Earthborn Elements Borax Powder has been my go-to for keeping my kitchen spotless.
  • Carpet Cleaner: Sprinkle borax on carpets to help remove odors and clean stains before vacuuming. Your carpet will thank you. I found MaxTite Borax particularly effective in getting rid of pet odors from my living room carpet.
  • Mildew and Mold Remover: Borax can kill mold and mildew on surfaces and prevent their regrowth. No more funky smells!
Borax for Household Cleaning
Borax: Your Cleaning Hero

Pest Control

  • Ant and Roach Killer: Mix borax with sugar to create a bait that ants and roaches can’t resist. It’s a sweet trap!
  • Flea Control: Sprinkle borax on carpets and pet bedding to help kill fleas and their eggs. Your pets will be flea-free.

Deodorizing

  • Odor Neutralizer: Borax can stop odors in garbage cans, diaper pails, and refrigerators. It keeps things fresh!
  • Pet Odor Eliminator: Use it to remove pet odors from carpets and upholstery. Even your dog will appreciate it.
Borax for Deodorizing
Freshen Up with Borax

Miscellaneous Uses

  • Rust Remover: Mix borax with lemon juice to remove rust stains from various surfaces. It’s like magic for metal.
  • Homemade Slime: Borax is a key ingredient in making homemade slime for kids’ crafts. Fun for everyone!
  • Fire Retardant: Use borax in DIY projects as a fire retardant for wood and other materials. Safety first!
Borax for Miscellaneous Uses
Borax: Versatile Home Helper

When I first found borax, I was amazed by its many uses. It helps with laundry, gets rid of pests, and more. Borax is now a key part of my cleaning routine. If you want a natural and effective cleaner, try borax. It might become your new best friend at home.

Household Uses of OxiClean

OxiClean is a well-known cleaner famous for removing stains. Its power comes from sodium percarbonate. Here are some ways to use OxiClean at home:

Laundry

  • Stain Remover: Effective on tough stains like grass, blood, wine, coffee, and food. When I used OxiClean Max Force Spray, it tackled even the most stubborn stains on my kids’ clothes.
  • Laundry Booster: Enhances the cleaning power of regular detergent and helps brighten whites and colors. I found OxiClean White Revive to be perfect for keeping my whites looking their best without the harshness of chlorine bleach.
  • Pre-Treatment: Soak stained garments in OxiClean solution before washing to break down stains. The OxiClean Odor Blasters Paks have been a lifesaver for pre-treating sweaty gym clothes.
OxiClean for Laundry
OxiClean: Stain Fighting Hero

Household Cleaning

  • Carpet Cleaner: Works on tough carpet stains and can be used in carpet cleaning machines. OxiClean Versatile Stain Remover is great for getting rid of pet stains and keeping carpets fresh.
  • Upholstery Cleaner: Removes stains from fabric furniture, car seats, and other upholstery.
  • Grout Cleaner: Cleans and brightens tile grout in bathrooms and kitchens. I wasn’t completely satisfied with some cleaners, but using OxiClean Outdoor Cleaner made my kitchen tiles look brand new.
OxiClean for Household Cleaning
OxiClean: Versatile Home Cleaner

Kitchen

  • Dishwasher Cleaner: Cleans and deodorizes the dishwasher, getting rid of residues.
  • Sink Cleaner: Removes stains and buildup from sinks and countertops.
  • Cookware Cleaner: Effective at removing baked-on food and stains from pots, pans, and baking dishes.

Bathroom

  • Tub and Shower Cleaner: Breaks down soap scum, hard water stains, and mildew. OxiClean Versatile Stain Remover Powder worked wonders on my bathroom tiles.
  • Toilet Cleaner: Helps to clean and deodorize toilet bowls.
  • Tile and Grout Cleaner: Cleans tiles and brightens grout lines.
OxiClean for Bathroom
OxiClean: Sparkling Bathroom Cleaner

Outdoor Uses

  • Patio Furniture: Cleans and removes stains from outdoor furniture.
  • Deck Cleaner: Removes stains and dirt from wooden decks and patios.
  • Garage Floors: Effective for cleaning oil stains and grime from concrete garage floors. OxiClean Outdoor Cleaner is my go-to for keeping the garage spotless.
OxiClean for Outdoor Uses
OxiClean: Outdoor Cleaning Power

Deodorizing

  • Odor Neutralizer: Gets rid of odors from laundry, carpets, and furniture.
  • Garbage Cans: Deodorizes and cleans garbage cans to remove lingering smells.

Miscellaneous Uses

  • Mattress Cleaner: Removes stains and odors from mattresses.
  • Shoes Cleaner: Cleans and freshens athletic shoes and sneakers.
  • Pet Stains: Great for removing pet stains and odors from carpets and upholstery. OxiClean Odor Blasters Powder is perfect for tough pet stains.

Using OxiClean has made my cleaning routine easier. Tough chores are now manageable. For laundry or outdoor messes, OxiClean is a great helper.

Comparison Table: Uses and Effectiveness

FeatureBoraxOxiClean
Laundry BoosterEnhances detergent, softens waterBoosts detergent, brightens whites and colors
Stain RemoverWorks on grease, oil, protein stainsEffective on grass, blood, wine, coffee, food stains
Dishwasher BoosterPrevents hard water spotsCleans and deodorizes dishwasher
All-Purpose CleanerCleans countertops, sinks, and bathroomsCleans tiles, grout, and fabric upholstery
Carpet CleanerRemoves odors, cleans stainsRemoves tough carpet stains
Mold and Mildew RemoverKills mold and mildewBreaks down soap scum, hard water stains, mildew
Odor NeutralizerStops odors in garbage cans, diaper pailsNeutralizes odors in laundry, carpets, furniture
SafetyNon-toxic, mild skin irritationCan cause irritation, use gloves
Environmental ImpactEco-friendlyHigher environmental footprint
Best ForEveryday cleaning, eco-conscious usersTough stains, deep cleaning tasks

Safety and Precautions: Borax vs OxiClean

Let’s discuss how to keep your cleaning routine safe and effective. When comparing Borax and OxiClean, it’s important to understand their safety profiles.

Safety First: Borax

Borax, or sodium borate, is a mild and natural cleaning agent. It’s been trusted for generations. Here’s what you should know:

  • Non-toxic, but handle with care: Borax is generally safe to use around the house. However, it’s still a cleaning product. Avoid ingesting it or getting it in your eyes. Once, I used Borax without gloves, and my hands felt a bit dry afterward. Lesson learned!
  • Mild skin irritation: If you have sensitive skin, wearing gloves is a good idea. Borax is safer around pets and kids compared to many other cleaners, but keep it out of their reach. Curious little ones and pets can still get into trouble!

Handling OxiClean

OxiClean is a bit more intense because it’s designed for tough stains. Here’s what you need to know:

  • Stronger chemicals: OxiClean’s main ingredient is sodium percarbonate. It is strong but can be harsh. Think of it as a strong friend who helps you move heavy furniture. They might scratch the floor by accident.
  • Use gloves, seriously: OxiClean can irritate your skin. I remember using it without gloves once, and my hands felt like they were on fire! Now, I always keep a pair of gloves handy.
  • Ventilate the area: When using OxiClean in closed spaces like bathrooms, ensure good ventilation. The fumes can be a bit much.

Comparing the Two: A Quick Look

FeatureBoraxOxiClean
ToxicityNon-toxic, handle with careStronger chemicals, use gloves
Skin IrritationMildCan cause irritation
Pet/Kid SafetyRelatively safeUse with caution
Environmental ImpactEco-friendlyHigher environmental footprint

Health and Environmental Concerns

Before buying cleaning products, check the EWG guidelines. Here’s a quick look at Borax and OxiClean:

  • Mule Team Borax Natural Laundry Booster:
    • Health Concerns: Some
    • Asthma/Respiratory: Some
    • Skin Allergies & Irritation: High
    • Developmental & Reproductive Toxicity: No data
    • Cancer: Low
  • OxiClean Stain Fighter Triple Power Liquid:
    • Health Concerns: Some
    • Asthma/Respiratory: Some
    • Skin Allergies: No data
    • Developmental Issues: No data
    • Cancer: Some

Cleaning can be fun, but safety is crucial. So, next time you’re gearing up for laundry day, remember these tips. Your hands (and possibly your nose) will thank you!

For more information, always check the Environmental Working Group guidelines before buying any cleaning products.

Practical Tips: Borax vs OxiClean

We’ve learned the basics and safety of Borax and OxiClean. Now, let’s look at some easy tips to get the best results from these products.

Practical Tips for Using Borax

Borax is very useful and can be used in many ways around your home. Here are some simple tips:

  • Laundry Booster: Add half a cup of Borax to your laundry to boost the power of your detergent. It helps remove stains, softens water, and keeps your clothes fresh. My favorite brand is Home & Country USA All-Natural Borax.
  • Stain Remover: For tough stains like grease or oil, mix Borax with water to make a paste. Put it on the stain, let it sit, and then wash as usual. Harris Borax Powder Laundry Booster works great for this.
  • Dishwasher Detergent Booster: Add a spoon of Borax to your dishwasher soap. This stops hard water spots on dishes and glassware. I love using Pure Original Ingredients Borax for this.

Practical Tips for Using OxiClean

OxiClean is a strong cleaner for tough stains and deep cleaning. Here are some tips to get the most out of it:

  • Stain Remover: For tough stains like grass, blood, or coffee, spray OxiClean Max Force directly on the stain before washing. It works wonders on stubborn spots.
  • Laundry Booster: Add a scoop of OxiClean White Revive to your laundry to brighten whites and colors. It’s perfect for keeping your clothes looking their best.
  • Pre-Treatment: Soak dirty clothes in OxiClean before washing. This helps remove stains and odors, making laundry easy.

Environmental and Health Considerations

Choose between Borax and OxiClean based on health and the environment.

  • Borax: Eco-friendly and non-toxic, but can cause mild skin irritation. It’s safer around pets and kids, making it a good choice for eco-friendly homes.
  • OxiClean: Great for deep cleaning but tougher on the environment. It has strong chemicals and can irritate skin. Use gloves and ensure good ventilation.

Related Post: Ajax vs Comet

Final Thoughts: Choosing the Right Product for You

Both Borax and OxiClean are good cleaners and can be helpful in your home. Here’s a quick summary to help you decide:

  • Borax: Great for daily cleaning and pest control. It’s natural and eco-friendly. It’s a gentle yet effective cleaner trusted for years.
  • OxiClean: Best for tough stains, deep cleaning, and brightening whites. It’s a powerful cleaner that tackles even the most stubborn dirt and grime.

In conclusion, whether you choose Borax or OxiClean depends on your cleaning needs and preferences. Both products have proven their worth in my home, and I’m sure they will do the same for you.

If you have any questions about Borax vs OxiClean, please comment below or contact me for more help. I’m here to assist you in making the best cleaning choice for your needs!

FAQ

Can I soak clothes in OxiClean overnight?

Yes, you can soak clothes in OxiClean overnight. I often do this to tackle tough stains. For best results, soak for 6-8 hours.

Does borax really whiten clothes?

Yes, you can soak clothes in OxiClean overnight. I often do this to tackle tough stains. For best results, soak for 6-8 hours. Your clothes will thank you!

What should you not mix with borax?

Do not mix borax with acids like vinegar or lemon juice. This combination can neutralize borax’s cleaning power. Stick to water or mild detergents for best results. Clean safely!

Amena

As a Household Products Expert, I specialize in evaluating and recommending top home and kitchen products. I provide practical insights to help consumers make informed decisions, ensuring quality and efficiency in their homes.

Leave a Comment